Flavors of Jamaica
Credit: Matt Keller Lehman

I tried to like reggae. Gave it years of my ears. Ears baptized by Bob Marley and Burning Spear, which led to Yellowman and Eek-A-Mouse, and ultimately down LKJ-shaped rabbit holes. I put in the time. But along the way Jamaican music never truly grabbed me. I had to try far less hard to like Jamaican food. Jerk chicken was my belly’s Bob Marley — a childhood ticket to the world of more serious island cooking. Since, I’ve thrown myself into brown stew and bammy, ackee and chicken feet, embracing a vibrant cuisine that’s not only stuck to my bones, but my heart and soul.

This love grew while living near Brixton, the hub of London’s Afro-Caribbean community. I’d literally walk down to Electric Avenue to score curry goat and chicken from barrel grills. Tracking down quality Jamaican food in Orlando has historically been more involved, but the latest outpost of Flavors of Jamaica makes it easy. Its SoDo location is convenient and spacious, its dining room bright with smiling faces and tasty eats.

Although meat features heavily in mainstream Jamaican, the menu quickly reminds us that Jamaica is an island. There’s saltfish and mackerel and shrimp and snapper, and that snapper can be ordered several ways. We ordered it whole, steamed and in an okra-thickened sauce ($34). It was fresh, smartly flavored and greedily devoured. Equally enjoyed was curry lobster ($28): generous chunks of lobster in a moreish curry so gloriously heavy with turmeric just a glance will stain your eyeballs.

And, yes, there was meat — bathed-in-gravy, falling-off-the-bone meat. Rich and silkily sauced oxtail ($25) was a thing of joy, while curry goat ($20) buzzed with the spice and aromatics that play so well with its trademark gaminess. Both paired perfectly with rice and “peas” (kidney beans), one of several sides among green beans, corn and cabbage. Apart from a swoon-inducing mac & cheese, sides are more complementary than stand-alone treat, but they do succeed in their sidekicking.

Flavors of Jamaica
Credit: Matt Keller Lehman

The range of tastes at Flavors of Jamaica is broad and includes dishes like “Rasta Pasta,” a jerk-seasoned and bell pepper-studded bit o’ fusion conceived in 1980s Negril — commonly referred to as “Alfredo” and a fixture on island menus. We opted for penne-based shrimp alfredo ($18) and were happy: creamy, carb-coma happy. Beyond the fixed fare, things are livelied up with daily specials and a rotating soup that has me headed back for conch chowder Sunday. More? There’s more. There’s breakfast: We were told to arrive early to ensure our share of the popular ackee and saltfish — another temptation, another reason to return. Yes, there’s a lot to like at Flavors of Jamaica — a lot to love, even.

And I’ll end where my love for Jamaican food began — jerk chicken ($19). At Flavors of Jamaica, it’s properly grilled and served with a side of sweet-heat jerk sauce. Verdict? Forget walking down to Electric Avenue. One bite and I knew I’d be driving down to South Ferncreek Avenue for more of the crisp, juicy bird that achieves a balance between chili heat and allspice that warms the brain. This is feelgood food, a feelgood that finds voice in friendly staff who will welcome, guide and thank you for waiting on certain dishes (like the curry lobster) that are cooked to order. No worries here. TLC is worth the wait — especially with a cold Red Stripe in hand, especially at Flavors of Jamaica. Now if I could just get them to turn off the Beres Hammond and turn on the Pixies. 

Flavors of Jamaica, 2610 S. Ferncreek Ave., 407-440-2193, flavorsofja.com.


Stay in the know in Orlando with Orlando Weekly's free newsletter.

Michael Murphy scribbles and thinks too much about food.