Winter Park Isle of Sicily mansion on private peninsula sells for $9.7 million

An ultra-private Winter Park mansion sited on an exclusive peninsula has just left the market.

The residence, located at 4 Isle of Sicily, is one of just 11 homes built on the peninsula, which veers into Lake Maitland. The sprawling, castle-like home sold March 29 for $9.7 million, according to Realtor.com.

With more than 9,500 square feet, the custom-built home sits on 1.41 acres and has five bedrooms and six baths. There’s also a two-story living room, a private library, formal dining room, massage room and wine room.

Outdoor features include a fire pit and seating area, fiber-optic lighting, five masonry fireplaces, a pool, an outdoor bath and an “oversized” four-car garage.

The property was previously listed for $10,950,000 in October 2023. The listing agent was Mick Night with Premier Sotheby’s International Realty.