John Cusack
John Cusack Credit: Courtesy AEG

It’ll be an iconic affair when John Cusack rolls through town to screen High Fidelity at Plaza Live, the venue whose architecture and programming is as revered regionally as High Fidelity is to its international audience of record snobs and the people who love/loathe them. 

Cusack stars as Rob Gordon in the dramedy — based on the 1995 novel by Nick Hornby — that follows a newly single Chicago record-store owner looking back on his five worst breakups while attempting to reconcile with Laura, his last girlfriend. The story plays out like the records the film revolves around, interspersed with dissections of relationship neuroses, fear of commitment and musical tastes. 

The film feels like a monologue-fueled mixtape where every actor gets to shine in a series of broken fourth walls, confessional angst and heated opinions, all while trying to navigate the world during their “carefree” but heavy 20s and 30s. The supporting cast of Iben Hjejle, a scenery-chewing Jack Black, Todd Louiso, Joan Cusack, Sara Gilbert, Lili Taylor, Natasha Gregson Wagner, Catherine Zeta-Jones, Lisa Bonet (whose daughter played Rob in yet another High Fidelity remake, the 2020 Hulu series) and Tim Robbins give it their all with sometimes cringey, sometimes heartbreakingly raw, irreverent and even surreal performances. 

Then there’s the music. The movie features a wealth of tastemaking 1990s and early ’00s fare: Royal Trux, Stereolab, Smog, the Beta Band, all the way back to the glorious past: The Clash, The Kinks, Stiff Little Fingers and Elton John, not to mention a cameo from the Boss himself, Bruce Springsteen. 

High Fidelity, like much of the work of director Stephen Frears (Dangerous Liaisons, The Grifters) and co-writer John Cusack (Say Anything, Gross Pointe Blank, Being John Malkovich), has a timeless quality that finds new audiences to this day. Its twin poles of arguing about music and fighting to keep a relationship going are evergreen activities, regardless of whether you’re soundtracked by scratchy singles or Bandcamp downloads. 

Originally a novel by Nick Hornby (About a Boy, Fever Pitch) set in London, High Fidelity could be set anywhere. Long before Hornby put pen to paper there were counterculture denizens gathering around the almighty record store — Amoeba in L.A., Chicago’s Wax Trax, Mondo Kim’s in NYC, Honest Jon’s in London and certainly Central Florida’s own institutions of Park Ave CDs, Rock-N-Roll Heaven and Retro Records — to find their tribe. That’s part of the beauty of this story: Where there’s music, there’s passionate people who are eager to share and also fight about it.

And where there’s music, there’s also always a “Rob Gordon,” Cusack’s character. The hyper-
intelligent hipster, emotionally immature, well-read, opinionated, obsessed, self-righteous, self-absorbed, maybe a legend in their own mind and a hopeless romantic. Cautionary tale or inspiration, depends on who you ask.

With all that in mind here are, with all apologies to Gordon, the “Top 5” thoughts from our little corner of the music and record-store world about High Fidelity.

5. Tierney Tough, The Pauses: “As someone who’s worked in record stores since the dawn of the iPod, they’ve always been a hub for community, education, discovery and world-building for me. Watching the film several times and reading the novel back then was what first introduced me to finding out that there were other weirdo music-obsessives out there and that there were places all over the country where we could belong.”

4. Bao Le-Huu, columnist, “This Little Underground”: “It’s really a perfect formula for a cult-film classic. Universal themes of love that trade in the mainstream schmaltz for an unapologetically indie sensibility. A smart thread of the needle there.”

3. Dominic Malik Major, Pulp City: “Is High Fidelity timeless, or is it a film about something timeless? There’s a difference. It captures a particular slice of music culture that was never everybody’s experience. The lack of hip-hop alone makes me wonder, timeless for whom? But music being tied to who we are, the people we love, the memories we carry and how we understand ourselves? Absolutely. That hasn’t changed and I don’t think it ever will.”

2. Tim Anderson, Enzian Theater: “What really got me was how much that kind of crazy specificity exists in these niche local spots. I remember back in high school going to Murmur Records and talking to Jim Leatherman (and buying a cassette single of “Jesus Built My Hot Rod” and a Dead Milkman T-shirt for Metaphysical Graffiti) and then when they closed up, getting Sandy [Bitman] to order Elvis Costello bootleg vinyl at Park Ave CDs when it was on Park Avenue!  And just how it was cool to hang out, listen to music and debate it all. Naturally that is mirrored in programming a movie theater.”

1. And in our top slot, the film’s director, Stephen Frears: He answered our call and gave us his two retrospective cents on the film: “Cusack and the other writers worked like a committee and they all had such strong, informed views about music. They were all obsessive and I depended on their ideas and then I was the one that said what worked where and when. John would be as such that every day he would see something on a shelf and ask why that wasn’t included in the film and its soundtrack. It needed an older person, myself, to make decisions. Had there been an alternative they would have gone mad. I went to a 25th anniversary screening with Nick Hornby and it was amazing how much it was loved. It’s certainly remarkable to see how one’s work continues with people years and years on. It really is a good film.”

The biggest thing an artist can hope for is that their work will be remembered and have a lasting effect. Everyone involved in High Fidelity can say they accomplished this. It’s an evergreen story that’s told with humor and passion. After all, we’re always ready to argue over and defend ’til the end a favorite song, record or performance. You can see proof of this enduring legacy live and in-person with John Cusack hosting an anniversary screening of High Fidelity at the Plaza Live Thursday.

7:30 p.m. Thursday, Nov. 19, The Plaza Live, 425 N. Bumby Ave., plazaliveorlando.org, $47-$125.


Stay in the know in Orlando with Orlando Weekly's free newsletter.