How the minority imposes its will in direct defiance of the majority's wishes

Tyranny of the few

The Wisconsin State Capitol in Madison
The Wisconsin State Capitol in Madison Photo via Adobe

For the first 22 decades or so of this republic, the rules were simple: If your side lost an election, you conceded defeat, stepped aside and let the other team take over. This peaceful transition of power has been a hallmark of the American system – indeed, of every democracy – a sign that, like it or not, the will of the people, exercised within the confines of the law, was paramount.

So it went after George W. Bush defeated Al Gore in 2000, despite the enduring controversy in Florida. And so it was, likewise, that the Obama administration ceded power to Donald Trump, despite Trump's popular-vote loss and his Russian assistance. The big exception, of course, came in 1860, but we settled that with a war.

Such was the state of things until November 2016, when a North Carolina Democrat named Roy Cooper had the gall to defeat Gov. Pat McCrory, a bumbling oaf who walked headfirst into the buzzsaw of HB 2, the so-called bathroom bill. Cooper didn't win by much – about 10,000 votes – but it was enough to set the Republican legislature on edge. Lawmakers used a special lame-duck session that was ostensibly about hurricane relief to rein in the new governor's powers, stripping him of his ability to make cabinet appointments without legislative approval, to hire some state workers and to name trustees to the state's university system, among other things. Republican leaders openly acknowledged the goal was to turn the Democratic governor into little more than a figurehead.

Some of those machinations didn't survive legal challenges, but the playbook did. And so, after decisive defeats in Michigan and Wisconsin last month, the lame-duck Republicans legislatures went to work, seeking to solidify their power regardless of what their voters wanted. In Michigan, Republicans sought to gut minimum wage and paid sick leave laws, to shift oversight of campaign finance rules away from the incoming secretary of state and to allow the legislature to intervene in lawsuits affecting the state, after the attorney general-elect won with a campaign promise not to defend the state's homophobic adoption law.

Wisconsin's play was even starker: Republicans there want to block the incoming governor from pulling out of a multistate lawsuit challenging the Affordable Care Act; weaken his control over a scandal-ridden economic development agency that he promised to close; undermine the attorney general-elect and give lawmakers the ability to hire a special counsel when they don't like what the attorney general is doing; lower voter turnout by shrinking early voting; and move the date of a 2020 Supreme Court election so that it doesn't overlap with the Democratic presidential primary, thus giving the Republican a better chance.

Legislatures have long used lame-duck sessions to pass controversial legislation: Don't Ask, Don't Tell became law after the 2010 midterms but before Republicans took power; and after the most recent midterms, North Carolina Republicans, having lost their veto-proof supermajorities, passed a voter ID law. But that's not what we're seeing now. These are naked, unabashed power grabs – sore losers subverting the will of the voters and kneecapping the next administration before it can begin.

And the people behind them aren't even trying to hide their intent: Without the power grab, Wisconsin House Speaker Robin Vos told his Republican colleagues, they "are going to have a very liberal governor who is going to enact policies that are in direct contrast to what many of us believe in."

Vos has a point: The voters of his state elected a man whose goals are in direct conflict with those of the Republican legislative majorities and, to a large degree, the people they represent.

All three of these states – North Carolina, Michigan, Wisconsin – are microcosms of a dynamic playing out all over the country, and more so during the Trump era: the rural-urban divide. Since the Obama presidency, Democrats have increasingly built their base around multicultural and educated urban coalitions, while Republicans have been forced to rely on white cultural conservatives in the sticks. This inherently gives Republicans a political advantage, with Democrats packed into fewer legislative and congressional districts. Add to that aggressive gerrymandering, and Republicans have locked in their power, regardless of what a majority of voters want.

Indeed, in North Carolina, Democrats won the statewide popular vote for both the House and Senate but will find themselves represented in the minority. The same thing happened in Michigan, where voters passed an initiative to end gerrymandering. In Wisconsin, where Scott Walker lost the governor's race, he carried 63 of 99 state Assembly districts.

This is the tyranny of the minority: Legislatures that derive their power only from geography and gerrymandering are using their majorities to undermine those whose power derives from actual people. (This same dynamic has given Republicans control of the U.S. Senate and enabled Trump to win the presidency.) It's cynical and shameless, sure, but it's also a fundamentally racist proposition that the vote of a white man in farm country should be worth more than that of a black or brown woman in the city.

If Donald Trump has taught us anything, it's that the norms underpinning American democracy are fragile. So long as the minority, emboldened by an increasingly homogenous base and petrified of losing power, is willing to impose its will in direct defiance of the majority's wishes, those underpinnings will only become weaker.

This is an existential threat to our system of government, and we damn well better begin treating it as such. The virus is only going to spread.


Since 1990, Orlando Weekly has served as the free, independent voice of Orlando, and we want to keep it that way.

Becoming an Orlando Weekly Supporter for as little as $5 a month allows us to continue offering readers access to our coverage of local news, food, nightlife, events, and culture with no paywalls.

Join today because you love us, too.

Scroll to read more Views + Opinions articles

Join Orlando Weekly Newsletters

Subscribe now to get the latest news delivered right to your inbox.