Movie: I, Robot

Our Rating: 2.00

In his classic novel I, Robot, science fiction author Isaac Asimov proposed three laws to which robots should abide. Those laws are hardwired into the near-sentient beings to prevent them from harming humans, thus dictating a "morality" to which the growing population of robots must abide.

Unfortunately, there are three laws that govern the film version of this tale that doom it to that ever-growing pile of trash otherwise known as big-budget science fiction – films that neither respect the "science" nor the "fiction" that inspired them:

1) Just because a movie "looks" smart, it doesn't make it so.

2) Whenever the director feels there's just too damn much "intellectualizing" going on, he has a bunch of people (or robots, or monsters) kick the living shit out of each other.

3) If a character ever warns an aggressor, "Now you're really starting to piss me off!" – the movie automatically sucks.

It's not that Asimov's book was so precious a literary gem that it couldn't have been helped with a bit of computerized special effects, or scenes of the lead characters showering, or some creative bloodletting. The novel's primary virtue was that it got us thinking seriously about the amount of responsibility we wish to give to the appliances in our life, with a nod to the idea that consciousness imitated is consciousness nonetheless.

The film manages to use these concepts to prop up a ridiculously clichéd script and by-the-numbers action sequences. It's a hard thing to pay attention to, as you'll be too busy analyzing the inherent impossibilities created by the plot holes and groaning loudly over the '70s-era TV-cop-show schtick. There's even a scene in which a homicide detective (Will Smith) throws his badge at his superior officer after the higher-up warns him about his too-independent and rogue-ish tactics! Are you kidding me?

Anyway, the story goes something like this: Del Spooner (Smith), a man who has reasons to hate the robot population that is omnipresent in the Chicago of 2035, investigates the apparent suicide of one Dr. Alfred Lanning (a bored-looking James Cromwell). The good doctor was a scientist in the employ of U.S.R., the creator of the brand-new robot, the NS5. The NS5 will replace all other models currently on detail helping people carry their groceries, protecting their homes and saving their lives if need be. Spooner is suspicious. He thinks the doctor was murdered by one of the NS5s: a particularly eloquent robot by the name of Sonny (Alan Tudyk).

Spooner is initially stonewalled in his investigation by Dr. Lanning's incredibly beautiful but cold assistant, Susan Calvin (Bridget Moynihan), who, by film's end, will have sufficiently loosened up to the point of wearing some stylish leather pants and letting her hair out of its original tight arrangement. Spooner, being the hip brutha he is, gets Susan to lighten up just in time to save the world from an army of robots hell-bent on taking their "three laws" to their natural conclusion.

Remember everybody: Science bad; homicide detectives who wear Converse All-Stars and eat sweet potato pie at Granny's house good. I just saved you eight bucks.


Since 1990, Orlando Weekly has served as the free, independent voice of Orlando, and we want to keep it that way.

Becoming an Orlando Weekly Supporter for as little as $5 a month allows us to continue offering readers access to our coverage of local news, food, nightlife, events, and culture with no paywalls.

Join today because you love us, too.

Scroll to read more Movie Reviews articles

Join Orlando Weekly Newsletters

Subscribe now to get the latest news delivered right to your inbox.