Indie horror director tries hand at crime thriller with ‘Cold in July’

Jim Mickle’s newest film is a suspenseful stab at a new genre

Cold In July
★★★ (out of 5 stars)

Over the last decade it seems that Hollywood has less and less interest in producing traditional crime thrillers unless they are bolstered by best-selling novels, mega movie stars (Brad Pitt, Liam Neeson, etc.) or eye-popping action scenes. Multiplex screens have relegated atmospheric suspense flicks with well-drawn characters and unexpected narratives (a staple of the 1990s) to the quieter release months of late winter and early fall. In 1993, three of the top 10 box office earners were thrillers (The Fugitive, The Pelican Brief, The Firm). There were none in the top 25 of 2013 (although Prisoners did far better business than expected).

Perhaps it’s the avalanche of quality cable series (True Detective, Hannibal, the latest episode of SVU) that has driven the suspense genre to the fringe. Or, more likely, it’s the international focus of the big studios. After all, marketing a movie like Malice, Primal Fear or even The Usual Suspects to South Korean and Chinese audiences must seem like a daunting proposition.

Which makes comparisons of filmmaker Jim Mickle to 1980s auteur John Carpenter all the more poignant. Mostly known as an indie horror director, Mickle applies both retro stylization and a postmodern sensibility to genre exercises. His 2010 film, Stake Land, and 2013’s We Are What We Are were well-received scare flicks that boasted unexpected intelligence and subversive thematic instincts. His latest, Cold in July, is a sweaty, seedy slice of East Texas neo-noir – though it was shot (like all his films) in upstate New York.

Set in 1989 and adapted from a novel by Joe R. Lansdale, it centers on family man and frame shop owner Richard Dane (Michael C. Hall), an ordinary guy with a mullet. Woken in the middle of the night by a home invader, he shoots the would-be burglar in fear for his family’s safety. This quickly puts him on a collision course with the victim’s ex-con father, Ben Russel (Sam Shepard). But what seems to be a simple tale of vengeance spins into a complicated web of police corruption, Southern mafia atrocities and vigilantism, culminating in a climactic shootout that’s reminiscent of the 1977 revenge actioner Rolling Thunder or even Martin Scorsese’s Taxi Driver.

Mickle, who co-scripted with Nick Damici, clearly savors the snaky, sleazy zigzags in Lansdale’s jarring hard-boiled tale, both embracing and defying its genre conventions. The story doesn’t dot every i or cross every t, but it certainly makes every ridiculously sinister turn stick. Mickle is a low-budget stylist, who creates a mood, tone and pace that compulsively pulls you into an ugly world of macho morality and chilling violence. Static shots give way to inventive – sometimes fussy – visual flourishes as Jeff Grace’s prickly synth score (a direct reference to Carpenter’s pulpy influences) bubbles beneath the plot’s unsettling mysteries.

Hall is convincing as the Everyman protagonist, and Shepard has one of the juiciest roles he’s had in years, going so far as to pen some of his own dialogue. But it’s Don Johnson, in his flamboyant cowboy duds and cherry-red Cadillac convertible, who steals the show. Weather-beaten but still sporting a twinkle in his eye, his Houston-based pig farmer-cum-private eye is brilliantly underplayed (if that can be believed) and wholly magnetic. It’s the kind of character you hope he gets to repeat in future projects.

While Cold in July touches on the responsibility fathers have for their sons, it’s an idea that could have used a little more fleshing out. While there’s little doubt that Mickle is a talented and innovative filmmaker with an impishly wicked sense of humor, he’s yet to prove himself an insightful study of human nature and relationships. As he catches more of Hollywood’s attention, let’s hope that bigger budgets mean greater depth of character.


Since 1990, Orlando Weekly has served as the free, independent voice of Orlando, and we want to keep it that way.

Becoming an Orlando Weekly Supporter for as little as $5 a month allows us to continue offering readers access to our coverage of local news, food, nightlife, events, and culture with no paywalls.

Join today because you love us, too.

Scroll to read more Movie Reviews articles

Join Orlando Weekly Newsletters

Subscribe now to get the latest news delivered right to your inbox.