A fumble on the goal line 


Tip O'Neill is generally credited with having said, "All politics are local." There is a certain truth to that, not just in politics but on all the stages of human activity. In Central Florida recently a number of things have happened to reinforce that notion in sport and other venues. The confluence of sport and education the last few weeks has been rich in both the ludicrous and the ironic.

Florida, which prides itself as an innovative state, adopted the concept of "charter schools" a few years ago amid claims that this would open the public schools to competition from entrepreneurs who would then bring new ideas and progress. Early this month it was reported that one such charter school was being opened in Kissimmee, which would be specifically designed to serve those teens and pre-teens who have dedicated themselves to ice skating. Budding Flemings, Boitanoes and Hardings would be able to attend classes in a modular classroom (read: trailer) run as a charter school by the ice rink owners.

One point of contention centered on the issue of a monthly fee for ice time and skating lessons. This seemed to suggest a form of tuition, something not allowed by state law. In the midst of the debate over this innovative educational experiment came insistent cries that public funds should not be used to train athletes. There was a sense of outrage that a school might be in the business of developing professional athletes as part of its educational mission.

In the war of words that followed, no one suggested that in much of Florida and America training athletes seems to be the primary mission of most schools. It is at the very least the one they do best. From the lower grades on up through the universities such things as football, basketball and even baseball or gymnastics are the primary activities in our schools. Standards are lowered, corners are cut, scholarships awarded, million-dollar budgets commonplace. Ohio State University proclaims in its media guide that a primary goal of their athletic program is to create a quality entertainment product.

Indeed, across Florida and over much of the country, Friday-night football seems to be the major reason for the existence of high schools. In small towns and big cities those Fridays are the high point of the community's social activity.

A few days after this flap came another instructive episode. Again the story emanated from Kissimmee. A football player from a high school whose team is weak was seeking to transfer to a school with a powerhouse football program.

The Florida High School Activities Association forbids transfers for sports purposes. The player therefore said he wanted to transfer to Football High because it had a more educationally enlightened form of scheduling (schedule of the school day, not football schedule).

The principal who was being abandoned accused his rival of trying to recruit his player -- a violation of state rules, but a common practice. The principal also was quoted as saying: "If we allow our athletes to change schools, we'll never build a football program."

That point states clearly the schools' objective. In fact, this particular high school has been graded the lowest in Osceola County for the quality of its education in a county in which the grades for all high schools are low.

David Porter, the Sentinel columnist who reported this story, suggests that principals might be better advised to concern themselves with the quality of the education in their schools rather than the quality of the football programs. The jilted principal might think about recruiting the excellent students at the rival schools in the county. He could then build a school noted for its academics and the number of students it sends on to college on academic scholarships.

If this were done, which principal would be most admired: the one whose high school won football games and failed to educate, or the one whose school produced quality education but couldn't win football games?

In Osceola County the answer is clear, as I suspect it is in most places around the country.

If, on the other hand, one school produced world-class skaters and one produced great football teams, it would be a tougher call. But the edge in most places would still go to the football school.

With this sort of enlightened leadership in our schools, one can only wonder why there is any shortage of workers in the fast-food industry.


More by Dick Crepeau

Newsletters

Never miss a beat

Sign Up Now

Subscribe now to get the latest news delivered right to your inbox.

Calendar

© 2016 Orlando Weekly

Website powered by Foundation